RedactedNarrative: Vessels #1 and #2 were both sailing (no motors in use) on Alum Creek Lake.  Vessel #1 was give way vessel and Vessel #2 was stand on vessel.  Vessel #1 attempted to give way to starboard and pulled the rudder the wrong way causing Vessel #1 to steer to the port and strike stand on Vessel #2 resulting in a hole in the front port side of Vessel #2